Review Form

paper title
(to be published in HarMArchive)

Please review the manuscript as you would want one of your manuscripts reviewed. Provide as many constructive comments and useful recommendations as possible.
Please return the completed Form as an email attachment addressed to kerri.kotta@eamt.ee.
Thank you!

(Note reviewer confidentiality. Reviewers should regard a submitted manuscript and the completed Review Form as confidential documents. They should not use or disclose unpublished information in a manuscript except with the permission of the author(s). Since there is no direct communication between author(s) and reviewer(s) concerning a manuscript, permission can only be obtained via the Editors.)
 
Reviewer name:
Reviewer email address:
Date:

1. General Recommendation for Editors (Check one with X and elaborate if necessary)

1.1. Accept as is:
1.2. Accept with minor revisions:
1.3. Accept subject to major revisions:
Do you agree to re-review the revised manuscript? Yes/No
1.4. Reject (please elaborate):

2. Summary Comments for Author(s) (please underline the appropriate word from the choices in parentheses or add your own opinion after them)
2.1. Originality of the paper (High/Medium/Low)
2.2. Adequate references to prior and related works by other authors (High/Medium/Low)
2.3. Accurate information (Yes/No)
2.4. Current information (Yes/No)
2.5. Methodology (Yes/No)
2.6. Writing style is generally (Excellent/Readable/Poor)
2.7. Ideas are clearly presented (Yes/No)
2.8. Meets submission requirements (abstract, length, style) (Yes/No)

3. Written Comments for Author(s)
(Please provide general comments supporting your recommendation, as well as remarks on specific issues of the paper, additional bibliography, etc.):